Saturday, December 5, 2020

Greed, Money, Power & Gaming the System

It’s hard to know where to begin, but at least if Donald Trump can pardon himself, Donny, Eric, Ivanka and Jared from federal criminal acts – and we are not entirely certain if he can – Joe Biden will not have to deal with the gut-wrenching process of presiding over an administration that is prosecuting the former President and his family, a most divisive possibility. If these pardons, and the whole host of co-conspirators and fellow possible felons who are likely to be released, stand, any criminal prosecution will have to flow from state criminal violations. We know New York is very much looking at that entire Trump coterie for both civil and criminal violations. 

At least that effort won’t be under Biden’s direct watch. If you want a little more detail on the constitutional right given to the president to pardon or commute, see my November 9th Pardon Me?  blog. Oh, and there is also an investigation going on right now into allegations that high profile lawyers were purportedly attempting to negotiate presidential pardons or commutations in exchange for political contributions as determined by the White House. Interesting.

Federal civil fines and penalties are not subject to exoneration under a presidential pardoning right. However, there some very interesting questions that arise by reason of these expected Trump pardons, including a self-pardon… which will include far more related violators than Trump’s immediate family. Trump is telling his associates that he is pardoning because he expects himself, his associates and his family to be subject to a prosecutorial vendetta by the Biden administration, not that he is admitting that there was any criminal activity. 

If anything, this expresses Trump’s view that the Department of Justice is subject to the whims of the president, pretty much how he treated former AG Jeff Sessions and how the current AG, William Barr has acted, more like the President’s personal attorney than as head of the department that is supposed to be neutral and charged with upholding the Constitution. Clearly, since that’s the way Trump ran his Attorneys General, as personal lackies, that would be what he would expect Biden to do as well. Under pressure from the President to investigate all that “widespread voter fraud,” even William Barr admitted that he was unaware of any supporting evidence.

Still this notion of what the AG’s role is or should be, as Trump sees it, is most troubling. It’s not as if a Biden-appointed prosecutor can simply jail members of the Trump cabal at will. There is this little intervening variable called a “jury,” which would have to convict by a unanimous decision. So, this raises the obvious question of why Trump feels the necessity of pardoning… unless he fears that a jury would convict because real provable crimes have been committed. Since Trump just might be continuing to commit criminal acts right now in asking state officials to violate their law and override the vote, he will probably wait until the last minute to pardon himself. Max out that benefit!

Next. Assume pardons are issued and stand. Clearly, Trump cannot pardon future federal crimes. Like lying to federal officers or refusing to testify facing a criminal contempt order. Once pardoned, the beneficiary of the pardon has no risk of prosecution for those pardoned actions, and if a blanket pardon is issued and holds, for any past federal criminal acts. One possible consequence might be, if there is a federal prosecution of criminal principals in Trump-related misdeeds who were not pardoned, can those pardoned be called to testify or produce evidence with no risk of self-incrimination against those not pardoned? In other words, without a right to invoke the Fifth Amendment against self-incrimination, which is no longer possible? And if they refuse and a court orders that testimony, are they committing a new federal crime if they defy that court order? Interesting. The pardon would not extent to that refusal to testify. And wouldn’t that information be fascinating, since it would like kill his and his family’s political future.

We can pretty much expect that when governmental agencies are free to examine the tax returns from Trump, his business and his family, they are quite likely to find “anomalies,” and if those anomalies move out of the world of justifiable tax planning into out and out evasion, therein lie some of Donald Trump greatest potential fears. Particularly, if the information on valuation set forth in those tax returns differs significantly from the information contained on the same assets in bank loan applications. That makes misrepresentations clearly intentional.

But the Trump organization is expert at gaming the system. Bankruptcy is their go-to pressure relief valve for fraudulent business operations or any business operation gone bad. And they are poised to take advantage of any twist of economic advantage, any governmental giveaway or subsidy or any loophole they think they can get away with. Trump properties – hotels and resorts – are easy ways for those seeking to curry favor with the President to funnel money to him through those assets. 

While Donald Trump and family have underplayed the pandemic, and he even recently called the continuing evidence of a escalating resurgence of the virus yet again a “hoax,” Trump has not been averse to taking advantage of the very stimulus programs that were enacted to help solve some of the economic pain inflicted by this purported “hoax.” “Sweeping data released by the Small Business Administration on who benefited from pandemic relief programs raises questions about the equitability and distribution of loans intended for small businesses, an initial analysis by NBC News shows.

“The analysis found that properties owned by the Trump Organization as well as the Kushner Companies, owned by the family of Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump's son-in-law and senior adviser, profited from the program…

“The analysis by NBC News, one of 11 newsrooms that sued for the release of data, also shows:

  • Over 25 PPP loans worth more than $3.65 million were given to businesses with addresses at Trump and Kushner real estate properties, paying rent to those owners. Fifteen of the properties self-reported that they only kept one job, zero jobs or did not report a number at all.

  • The loans to Trump and Kushner properties included a $2,164,543 loan to the Triomphe Restaurant Corp., at the Trump International Hotel & Tower in New York City. The company reported the money didn’t go to keeping any jobs. It later closed.

  • A company called LB City Inc, which is at Kushner’s Bungalow Hotel in Long Branch, New Jersey, received a loan for $505,552.50 that it used to keep 155 jobs.

  • Two tenants at 725 5th Avenue, Trump Tower, received more than $100,000 and kept only three jobs.

  • Four tenants at the Kushner-owned 666 5th Avenue combined received more than $204,000, and retained only six jobs.”   NBC News, December 1st.

As Trump pressures GOP election officials and governors to violate their own state statutes and overrule the voters to name Trump-supporting electors, and he has chastised the Republican governor of Georgia for not cancelling the upcoming Senate runoff election, Trump is effectively asking those fellow Republicans to break the law, probably violating criminal statutes, to allow him to continue to rule. 

He has suggested he has no plans to attend the Inauguration on January 20th and may instead hold a Trump rally in anticipation of another Trump run for the presidency in 2024. While many in his base will remain loyal, and while he is likely to have a loud social media voice against anyone with an opposing view, the likelihood of a second Trump presidency, in my opinion, is ZERO. Trump’s legacy will probably focus on his quest for permanent power, ignoring the pandemic as he seeks to overturn a legitimate election. Failure was not an option, but he failed miserably.

As Trump fiddles with his thirst for power, ignoring just about everything else except golf outings and Christmas parties, “the country he leads continues to smash coronavirus records. On Wednesday [12/3], the U.S. hit a pair of grim pandemic milestones, reaching new daily highs in hospitalizations and deaths. The country tallied nearly 200,000 new cases, while reporting more than 100,000 virus-related hospitalizations and reaching a new high of 2,760 deaths in a single day. The overall death toll since the pandemic started now stands at more than 273,000 and the pace of deaths in America due to the virus is only quickening.” Slate.com, December 3rd. 

I’m Peter Dekom, and I suspect that history will paint Donald J Trump as an evil, most corrupt American president by miles, and a manipulative lying criminal-autocrat in it for one reason and one reason only: himself.


Friday, December 4, 2020

Cars, Trucks, the Future, Driverless and the Occasional Now

Back in March, CBS’ 60 Minutes did a piece on driverless trucks: “Few are aware that driverless 18-wheelers are already on the road. The test runs on highways have humans in them just in case sensors or computers fail, but an autonomous trucking executive says by next year, they won't. The future of freight on America's roads can be a driverless one, this executive says. And that's news to many, especially the truck drivers who stand to lose their livelihoods…

“‘We believe we'll be able to do our first driver-out demonstration runs on public highways in 2021,’ says Chuck Price, chief product officer at TuSimple, an autonomous trucking firm with operations in the U.S. and China. With a proving ground in Arizona, TuSimple is one of several firms hoping to make billions in an industry that moves over 70% of the nation's goods

“Sensors, cameras and radar devices affixed to the rig feed data to the artificial intelligence-driven supercomputer that controls the truck. Price says his product is superior to others. ‘Our system can see farther than any other autonomous system in the world. We can see forward over a half-mile… day, night and in the rain. And in the rain at night,’ he says.” CBS, 60 Minutes Overtime, March 13th. Deployment? That’s 2021 for those who care! There are a few issues that are still being ironed out, challenges like dealing “with construction zones and median crossovers that direct traffic to what the robot would typically think is the wrong side of the road.” Trucks.com, October 13th. All solvable. Still, testing requires someone sitting in the driver’s seat.

But having someone in the driver’s seat as a back-up isn’t always reassuring. Returning from the Pacific Northwest over the last Christmas holiday, we passed a Tesla sedan with the seats in full recline, driver fast asleep. Apparently, that reality is not uncommon. “Police in Canada have charged a man with speeding and dangerous driving after he was found asleep at the wheel of his self-driving car as it travelled at 150km/h [93 mph] down a highway in the province of Alberta.

“Announcing the charges…, the Royal Canadian Mounted police said that on 9 July they received a complaint that a Model S Tesla vehicle was speeding on the highway near the town of Ponoka… ‘The car appeared to be self-driving, traveling over 140km/h [87 mph], with both front seats completely reclined and both occupants appearing to be asleep,’ the RCMP said in a statement… After the police flashed their lights, however, the Tesla electric vehicle reportedly sped up to ‘exactly’ 150km/h, according to police. The speed limit on most of Canada’s highway network is 110km/h.

”The driver, a 20-year-old man from neighboring British Columbia, was charged with speeding and given a 24-hour license suspension for driving while fatigued… The province has also decided to charge the driver with dangerous driving, and he is due to appear in court in December.

“The proliferation of self-driving vehicles, pioneered by the electric car company Tesla, has posed a challenge for regulators trying to determine the safety and effectiveness of the on-board systems… In January, an Ontario driver was charged with reckless driving after officers spotted him using both hands to floss his teeth as his vehicle sped along the highway at 135 km/h [83 mph].” The Guardian (UK), September. There have been a few accidents where Tesla’s autonomous driving system well… failed. 

Tesla’s Elon Musk, now purportedly the world’s fourth richest person, is focusing on what many see as a bigger problem than driverless command and control: range for totally electric vehicles. Many think Tesla is a wildly over-valued company; there are also doubters who see Tesla coming up against some real competition and making promises about new battery capacity that just might not be as close to broad commercialization as the company suggests.  Susan Karlin, writing for the September 20th FastCompany.com, assesses Tesla’s challenges:

“CEO Elon Musk is expected to unveil breakthrough battery technology and automotive architecture, including a longer-lasting ‘million-mile’ battery that could drop electric vehicle (EV) prices to those of gasoline cars and contribute to the electric grid. And then there’s the question of whether Musk will stand by earlier promises to deliver Level 5, fully autonomous vehicles (AVs) this year, especially in the wake of a Consumer Reports review this month that found Tesla’s current self-driving capabilities falling short.

“But will Tesla be able to deliver on those promises, from game-changing batteries to true AVs in 2020? The rumors that swirl around the company, its erratic founder, and inflated valuation cloud a more complicated truth. To achieve its goals, Tesla will have to pull together an assemblage of research, data collection, and acquired technologies to enable a battery that could revolutionize EVs, as well as beat out a host of self-driving competitors that are in many ways closer to achieving driverless vehicles than Tesla.

“Already producing the world’s leading EV, Tesla has also become the most valuable auto company in the world, despite selling millions fewer cars than traditional car manufacturers. It’s the first automaker to sell more than 1 million EVs, with its bestselling Model 3 topping 500,000 units. Tesla stock—which was going for $2213 a share before its 5:1 split on August 31—has enjoyed a 414% price increase this year, with a market cap of $412 billion, a figure that many analysts and even Musk himself deem overvalued. The stock’s performance has polarized analysts and investors on whether to value Tesla as a car or technology company.”

Whatever else is said or done, we are inevitably heading into a universe of accelerating automotive change. Our highways and bridges – without even looking at our power grid, dams and levees – are about two trillion dollars or more short of what is needed to fix and upgrade for current demand levels. One tiny little catch: Congress, already slammed from deficits from COVID stimulus costs and the world’s most ill-conceived mega corporate tax cut, is exceptionally unlikely to appropriate the necessary funds to fix this anomaly anytime soon. Driverless vehicles at least offer us the ability to use what we have more efficiently, stretching our ability to use existing infrastructure for a longer time. Not that much longer, I might add.  And that’s just part of a bigger reality.

Lots of jobs will be lost, an impact from artificial intelligence that will continue to decimate a spectrum of human skills well beyond the blue-collar workers already affected. Doctors, lawyers, financial planners and analysts and clerical jobs are going to be hit hard too. Hardly just truck drivers. While we need adequately paid labor to fund our 70%-plus consumer economy, this massive shift to autonomous worker-replacement stands to redefine our political, social and economic assumptions and underlying systems… just when the COVID recovery will most desperately need jobs for all those individuals whose employers faded from the plague.

    I’m Peter Dekom, and as rough a ride as the current combination of a pandemic plus political polarization is causing, hang on to your seats, because you ain’t seen nothin’ yet!


Thursday, December 3, 2020

A Matter of Adjustment

If you’ve traveled to the Miami area in the past year, and if you were there after a heavy rain (pretty common), did you happen to drive through flooded streets (first picture above)? Been on a drive down through the Keys? Scary, huh? Maybe, you live in New York City and enjoyed the massive flooding, right down into the subway system, after superstorm Sandy in 2012 (second picture above). Or maybe you enjoyed the coastal erosion in the Carmel, California in 2011 (third picture above). How would you like to drive down a stretch of the Highway 1 at Gleason Beach (the big picture above from CalTrans)? 

Today, I don’t want to proselytize over the accelerating devastation in the United States from global climate change based on the masses of photographs of droughts, wildfires, hurricanes, storm surges and flooding from rivers overflowing their banks. If you do not believe that climate change is real or that God would never let that happen, you are a very big part of the problem. If you believe that the trillions and trillions of dollars of real damage are worth paying for indefinitely to support heavy industry and fossil-driven energy – a huge subsidy to industries that we all know are not sustainable – I think that you should be required to double your taxes to help pay for the resulting clean-up, recovery, or downright loss. 

Today’s focus is on one relatively small climate change story, one that seems like a local California tale with little or no impact on most of us. Even the hard dollar cost is relatively minor. But how many of those “little” stories, those “little” inconveniences, are there? The kind that don’t get hurricane or wildfire headlines but are aggregating into “massive.” All this as our infrastructure, without taking climate change damage into consideration, was already passing two trillion dollars just for basic repairs and simple upgrades. And those are the federal government’s conservative estimates. The American Society of Civil Engineers thinks that number is woefully too small; they believe that the nation's roads, dams, levees, airports and water and electrical systems need $4.6 trillion of work – far more than the entire federal government spends in a year. Oh, and we seem to have depleted state coffers and incurred additional federal deficits by the trillions of dollars just to deal with pandemic. More “deferred” maintenance or perhaps an opportunity to invest in infrastructure and alternative energy to help reignite the economy and slow climate change? Depends on whether you are a Republican or a Democrat.

Look at the big photograph above. CalTrans (the state agency in charge of building and maintaining roads) has watched 11 homes fall away and a new guard rail drop into the sea, rather aware that this section of Highway 1 in Northern California’s Sonoma County is just one of so many scenic California highways that are obviously not long for this world. The solution was thought to be simply to rebuild and reinforce what was. Since 2004, California wasted $10 million on that failed band aid approach. The road needs to be moved at least 350 feet inland. They call that a “managed retreat.” That would take a further $73 million, assuming the project stays on budget. Will what you see in the above picture even be there next year if nothing is done?

California realizes that doing nothing is not an option. “The ambitious project — approved this month after more than a decade of planning — comes at a time when city and state leaders across California are waking up to the social and economic disasters of sea level rise. At least $8 billion in property could be underwater by 2050, according to recent legislative reports, with an additional $10 billion at risk during high tides. Heavier storms and more intense cycles of El Niño could make things even worse… In a set of targets guided by Gov. Gavin Newsom’s administration, many agencies agreed this year to prepare California for at least 3.5 feet of sea level rise by 2050.

“The painful reimagining of Gleason Beach offers a glimpse into the future for other communities now clashing over the costs and compromises of living by the sea. At the heart of this $73-million project is a reckoning over what is worth saving — and what is worth sacrificing — and whether it’s possible to redesign a treasured landscape so that it survives into the future.

“‘It seems daunting; it’s a lot of change to cope with, but it’s also an opportunity for communities to think about: What are the coastal resources we want to have access to 50, 100 years from now?’ said Tami Grove, the California Coastal Commission’s statewide transportation program manager. ‘It gets lost, sometimes, when people are worried about everything that we’re going to lose to sea level rise — but there are things that we’re going to be able to choose and enhance and design into the future if we start planning now.’

“Maintaining this critical stretch of Highway 1 has been a decades-long saga. It is the only evacuation route for many residents, as well as the only way to reach many of Sonoma County’s beaches and sweeping vistas — the economic and cultural soul of the region… Photos from the 1970s show more than 20 bluff-top homes and a wide sandy beach buffering the highway from the sea. But the particularly unstable cliffs in this area have been eroding about 1 foot a year on average, exacerbated by sea level rise and sudden landslides.” Los Angeles Times, November 30th. 

As I said, this is just a little story about one very small stretch of a scenic coastal roadway. Coastal states would seem to more vulnerable… kind of the same assumption that rural states made about the spread of COVID-19. But make no mistake, there isn’t a single US state that does not face billions and billions of dollars of infrastructure damage and costs directly related to climate change. Add to that the private sector economic losses to residents, businesses, employment and natural resources that are likely to be a vast multiple of the damage incurred by governmental entities. Time has run out. Now.

I’m Peter Dekom, and to those who simply say our business world and our tax base cannot afford to do what is necessary to stem climate change damage… I have to ask, can we afford not to?


Wednesday, December 2, 2020

Biden, His Time

It’s the Economy Stupid

The first and critically important aspect of the Biden presidency is simply to ignore and not engage in any sort of give-and-take with Donald Trump. Trump and his ardent followers have pledged to remain a constant thorn in Biden’s side, to gridlock Congress if they can and turn the President-elect into a one-term president. That just might happen anyway by reason of Mr. Biden’s age, but becoming defensive with Trump (based on success claims that are dramatic fabrications) empowers Trump and keeps him in the headlines. Remember Trump’s failure to lead combined with his ability to mislead and destabilize has led to yet unmeasured tolls of suffering and death plus a two-fold slam to the economy: one from mismanaged trade policies and a bigger one of failing to understand that the pandemic cannot be delinked from economic recovery.

That the Trump administration failed to achieve the economic growth rates from both the Clinton and Obama eras is mired in a constant mythological spin that Trump got the economy right, and they did not. Wrong. His destabilizing and erratic push-me/pull-you tariff wars, tilting toward bilateral trade agreements in a multilateral world, believing in bullying and punishment through trade policies and his racist “America First” slogan (a Ku Klux Klan slogan from the 1920s) trade mantra have created a massive economic disadvantage for both US farmers and “business America.” Trump is over. Time and demographic shifts are not on his side. His legal woes are just beginning. His health is already beginning to pull him down; his weight, eating habits and exposure to the inevitable aftereffects of his bout with COVID-19 will not combine well with the stress of his election loss. 

Obviously, containing the pandemic is Biden’s “job one.” Trump’s “Operation Warp Speed” has created skepticism in the efficacy of a vaccine that must be overcome if herd immunity and economic recovery are going to work on a reasonable time frame. Scientists combining with influencers in a massive social media campaign are necessities once one or more vaccines are proven safe. Those same influencers can help convince as many Americans as possible to “mask-up” and practice social distancing until the virus is contained. Otherwise, we can expect at least another million infections, with long-term effects now showing up in those who were otherwise asymptomatic, and 100,000 additional deaths. Further, Trump’s failure to provide the necessary funding and infrastructure for local deployment of a viable vaccine must be remedied immediately. 

While some Wall Streeters see a V-shaped recovery if we can just get everything open immediately, I suspect they either failed their US history courses or didn’t take them. Recovering from massive devastation never is V-instantaneous. NEVER. Economies left to stagnate and follow a path of laissez faire governmental policy can sputter for years or die entirely (think: banana republics and post WW-I Europe and the Great Depression in the United States). 

The pandemic recovery economy needs two distinct capital infusions: one to get those Americans (individuals and businesses) through until there is COVID-19 containment, and two to reprime the American economic pump. We need to very careful about our metrics of success. A rising stock market and business tax cuts do not create jobs and promote general economic well-being. Likewise, obsessive belief in a rising gross domestic product can be equally misleading. If the top 5% of earners explodes with success but the rest of the economy either stagnates (at already depressed levels) or even contracts, GDP could still rise. We need to focus on “average, mean and median” income metrics and a detailed analysis of unemployment statistics. 

By the time Biden takes office, the next national election will take place at the end of 2022. Stimulus polices will not face the instant scrutiny that Congress faced (faces, if you take the Georgia runoff into account) in the past few months. If Congress can indeed get out of its own way, find a bi-partisan compromise, and work for a genuine and sustainable recovery. Or it can dig in stubborn heels, resurrect the Trumpian blame-game, and watch public animus rise to the boiling point. There are obvious priorities.

First, and hopefully Congress learned this from its uncoordinated initial pandemic stimulus efforts, just throwing money “out there” is wildly inefficient, only partially effective and generates deficits without sufficiently offsetting benefits. Second, wage earners and small businesses can be the most vulnerable in the aggregate but lack the large-scale visibility of big business and market segments with major lobbying capacity. It is on these smaller individual units that the initial, phase one stimulus allocations must be focused. Lesson: target precisely what you want to fix or help, create monitoring and tracking systems and enforce responsibility. Corollary: prepare to adjust your allocations to smooth out unintended consequences and fill the unanticipated cracks.

Thus, phase one is keeping us alive. Writing for the November 20th TheConversation.com, R. Andrew Butters, assistant professor of business economics and public policy at Indiana University and a visiting scholar at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, explains: “One likely focus for the Biden team will be income support, much like what we saw in parts of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act, which offered generous unemployment benefits – the last of which will expire in December. But not all aid is created equal, and economists favor stimulus with large multiplier effects – that is, how much economic activity is generated for every dollar of spending.

“For example, if I have US$1,200 in extra income from the government, I might go out and spend some of that on a nice meal with my family at a local restaurant. The restaurant then uses that money to pay its employees and buy more supplies from other businesses, both of which then spend the money on other things they need. The more everyone spends from that initial dollar, the higher the multiplier. If a lot of people like me use that extra money for savings or to pay off credit card debt, the multiplier goes down, making the stimulus less impactful.” How long, the amount and the number of such stimulus packages will truly depend on whether Americans are truly willing to do what it takes to contain this pandemic. Failing to apply scientific reality simply draws out the pain and creates a much deeper hole to crawl out of. 

Phase one – income support – keeps us alive, but without additional capital infused into the system, re-priming the pump (phase two), the expected recovery could take a decade or more. As Professor Butters puts it: “[W]hile providing more income support will help those most hurt by the pandemic, it won’t necessarily bring jobs back. Stimulus packages that attempt to invest in certain sectors of the economy to generate demand for labor and create jobs could go further in providing a longer-term impact on the economy. 

“So I wouldn’t be surprised if the administration also provides stimulus that aims to bolster hiring, such as by spending billions of dollars on infrastructure. The 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act that Biden worked on included this type of infrastructure spending.

“Stimulus spending should also not overlook state and local governments, which are in desperate need of support to avoid severe cuts in services, such as transportation, education and health, which would seriously hamper any economic recovery.” Beware of that old, mega-failed Republican mantra of believing that tax cuts for the rich trickle down to the rest of us. They never have, and I suspect, they  never will. 

Assuming Congress is even willing to get there, there are questions as to whether the government uses private industry to implement the infrastructural/new job growth or adopts an FDR New Deal direct employment model (a la his Civilian Conservation Corps and the Works Progress Administration). 

The benefits for the nation as a whole are obvious: improved economic efficiency with enhanced infrastructure, a direct assault on climate change by focusing on alternative energy and the ability to target particularly hard hit regions of the United States where economic realities have severely hurt the local industries. This same vigor could also apply to reconfiguring our national healthcare policies to insure access to affordable medical care for all Americans while expanding job growth in the sector. Yes, we can!

I’m Peter Dekom, and there are many paths to bring America back to where it should be and can be… and many more paths to accelerate the great unraveling.


Tuesday, December 1, 2020

A Loan Again, Unnaturally

(Graphic: David Foster)

***Updated 12/1/20 10:45 pm EST

One of the major motivations for first-time, younger voters this past November is the absurdity of their level of US student debt from post-secondary education. With tuition costs rising at double the rate of inflation, that key to upward mobility – specialized training and education – slammed into the lives of Y and Z generations like a tsunami after a major earthquake. Average debt for a four-year undergraduate education is almost $40 thousand, and for those beyond in professional schools (law, medicine, business), they often face serious six figures of post-graduation loans. Boomers never had to deal with student debt at this level, adjusted for inflation, and even Xers were not hit as hard. The above chart says it very clearly.

For profit trade schools, much like Donald Trump’s fraud-based Trump University, were and some continue to be money-churning mills based on false promises, unrealistic earning potential, and easy qualification for federally- assisted or provided debt. Under the malignant leadership of Department of Education head, Betsy DeVos, those money-mills found governmental support even as many were shuttered because of illegal practices, as the students encumbered by lingering debt (and closed schools) were for the most part left to twist in the wind. While there were theoretical outs for defrauded students, DeVos found ways to make debt relief complex if not completely elusive. Educational loan forgiveness has become a hot political issue.

Simply put, Betsy DeVos has always been all about protecting the creditor schools, regardless of their misfeasance. At the virtual 2020 Federal Student Aid (FSA) Training Conference on Tuesday [12/1], “DeVos took aim at proposals to cancel student debt, a proposal that the incoming Biden administration campaigned on, calling debt forgiveness ‘the truly insidious notion of government gift giving.’… ‘We’ve heard shrill calls to ‘cancel,’ to ‘forgive,’ to ‘make it all free,’ ’ Devos added. ‘Any innocuous label out there can’t obfuscate what it really is: wrong.’… She also condemned the Democrat-supported idea of providing free college to lower-income Americans, calling the proposal ‘a socialist takeover of higher education.’” Yahoo! Finance, December 1st. An ultra-right wing “let them eat cake” billionaire heiress, DeVos’ callous disdain for students in need, defrauded and misled, is hard to fathom. That calls herself a Christian borders on the absurd.

“New forgiveness aside, the mechanisms through which defrauded student borrowers or borrowers who served 10 years in public service (from veterans to firefighters) can apply for debt discharge have broken down, especially during the Trump administration.‘…One of the most frustrating and heartbreaking things, talking to thousands and thousands of student loan borrowers over the years, is that borrowers are entitled in many instances to have their loans totally forgiven and given a second chance in their financial lives, under the system that Congress created,’ Seth Frotman, head of the nonprofit Student Borrower Protection Center (SBPC), told Yahoo Finance… What has happened over time, according to Frotman, ‘is that incompetence at the Department of Education and illegal practices within the student loan industry has unnecessarily and unconscionably blocked borrowers from the relief that they were promised under law.’” Yahoo! Finance, November 25th. Many believe it was not DOE “incompetence,” as you can clearly see from DeVos own words above.

For those who did not complete their degrees, even at the most legitimate institutions of higher learning, the student debt remained even as the earning-improving degree was never obtained. For those who did graduate, a hostile job market, amplified by a housing affordability crisis and an economy crushing pandemic made that which was intolerable impossible. The revision of the US Bankruptcy Code in 2005 made bankruptcy relief from student debt well-neigh impossible. 

Although the Republican Party seems not to have noticed, almost 60% of Millennials (a number that seems to be rising with even younger generations) have received at least some formal post-secondary education. Most carry student debt. Two-thirds of those first-time voters cast their ballots for Joe Biden, who promised to address this excessive debt load through a program of student loan forgiveness. Having never lived through the red scare and the anticommunism that drove US foreign policy for decades after WWII, these debt-carriers reject the misapplied accusations of “socialism.” They just do not care. Younger voters are growing. Older voters are dying off. Hint!

The groundswell of ignorance that actually conflates social programs – like Social Security, Medicaid, SNAP food programs, universal healthcare – with government ownership of societal wealth (land, factories, business, farms, etc.), which is the true definition of “socialism,” continues to lead uninformed voters by the nose. The exceptional attraction of a very large segment of Millennials and Z’s to “Democratic Socialist” Bernie Sanders and the Progressive “Squad” in the House of Representatives is very telling. Changes are afoot. 

If Artificial Intelligence continues to replace an increasing number of college-education-required jobs, you can certainly look to a rise in the potential escalation of true socialist alternatives in mainstream American politics. If the economy will not reignite rapidly after the pandemic is under control, you can expect pressures to implement direct government employment in infrastructure projects a la FDR’s New Deal. If by some miracle, Joe Biden is able to overcome the expected congressional gridlock and architect a path to some form of federal student loan debt relief, the policy issues that will surface will rattle our entire notion of education to its core.

Who gets loans forgiven? Everyone? Rich families and high earners? How much? Is it fair to those who paid their debts with maximum sacrifice? And what about the causes that made the debt rise that fast: “Large-scale cancellation of debt ‘doesn't solve the crisis long term,’ Kevin Carey, vice president for education policy and knowledge management at the D.C.-based think tank New America, told Yahoo Finance Live (video above). ‘Everyone acknowledges that if we don't change the underlying system that produced that debt in the first place, whatever debt we forgive, the total amount will just start to rise again.’

“The fundamental issue, according to Carey, is a system where ‘the federal government printing money and lending it out based on what colleges choose to charge.’… In other words, the real problem is that the average cost of total tuition, fees, room and board rates charged for full-time undergraduate students in degree-granting institutions in the U.S. has increased more than two times the general U.S. inflation rate.” Yahoo! Finance. Professors in business or professionally-directed fields are being paid at unprecedented salaries, many into mid-level six figures, which when added to their outside consulting and publication fees has made many academics into millionaires.

For students at prestigious public universities in Germany, where student fees are negligible and tuition non-existent, there is no student debt crisis. Yet Germany continues to produce products of exceptional technological quality, provide scientific and financial services at the highest level and sustain one of the most robust economies on earth. As we face a flurry of unfounded, if not patently absurd, conspiracy theories and a narcissistic President, not giving any thought to American pandemic victims and unwilling to relinquish his office after a sound thrashing at the polls, it most certainly time to question whether the United States has the best economic and political system in the world… or even an average one.

I’m Peter Dekom, and if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck…