Wednesday, November 25, 2020

The COVID-19 Virus Should Send a Thank-You Note

Sure, we have vaccines that seem as if they will be released imminently, and that is a very good thing. But for most of us, we will not have the ubiquitous access we might like for a while, even assuming a willingness to accept the two-stage inoculation process. Even as essential workers, particularly healthcare workers and super-vulnerable people, might have early access in the next month or two, most of us will not see that vaccine availability until at least the spring.  

We still have issues getting the vaccine to the people, and federal government is not helping states with depleted budgets fund the efforts (which are mostly state driven). Both the Pfizer and the Moderna vaccines require refrigeration (Pfizer literally at 70 degrees below zero Celsius)… and estimates from governmental sources suggest that by March, we may face well over four hundred thousand total deaths from the virus. With no exception, every qualified physician – knowledgeable about epidemiology – tells us that wearing masks and social distancing are essential. Even some red state governors who were vehemently opposed to mask mandates have relented (e.g., Iowa, Utah, North Dakota, Ohio, etc.) as their states face a lack of hospital (particularly ICU) beds to address their skyrocketing infection rates.

But for so many Republicans, they actually believe that mandating the wearing of mask anywhere is a political and not a medical statement. Too many red state legislators, embracing what is uniformly viewed as Donald Trump’s view of masks as always a matter of individual choice, despite the impact of infected individuals on those around them, cannot bring themselves to protect… even themselves. For the record, there is absolutely no constitutional right for individuals to ignore properly issued mask regulations any more than there is a right randomly to discharge firearms in public.

These individual state houses, where legislators gather in close proximity, are potential hotbeds for spreading the virus. Yet in many red state houses, legislators believe that passing a mask mandate for the legislature itself sends the wrong message to the Trump supporters who elected them. “Nearly 200 legislators nationwide have tested positive for the virus, and four have died from COVID-19 since the pandemic began, according to figures compiled by the Associated Press. At least four dozen Mississippi lawmakers tested positive in the largest outbreak in a legislature, where masks were encouraged but not required [pictured above].

“The Missouri Legislature postponed a special session focused on virus relief after a coronavirus outbreak among lawmakers, and a Tennessee lawmaker said she won’t be able to spend Thanksgiving with her mother after attending a hearing where legislators weren’t wearing masks.

“Health experts warn that the public is taking its cue from elected officials at a time those officials are trying to restrict or discourage indoor gatherings that are fueling a rapid rise in cases… ‘We know it works, but if political leaders don’t stand behind their public health officials and say we need to do this, a significant portion of the public may not follow,’ said Dr. Jeffrey Levi, professor of health policy at George Washington University.

“[Some l]egislatures have taken steps to try to limit the virus, with some allowing remote voting and others meeting in larger venues to allow more spacing. Arkansas’ House, for example, met in a basketball arena for two sessions last spring but will return to the Capitol next year.

“Twelve Arkansas lawmakers have tested positive for the virus over the last month, the second-largest known outbreak in a state legislature… The latest outbreak began after lawmakers convened at the Capitol for budget hearings last month. The budget panel had adopted a mask rule that didn’t require lawmakers to wear them when speaking into a microphone, drinking or if they were at least six feet away from other people…

“House and Senate leaders in Oklahoma announced plans to impose a mask mandate for employees who work inside the Capitol after two lawmakers recently tested positive. But legislative leaders acknowledged that individual legislators couldn’t be forced to wear masks.

“An outbreak among Missouri state senators that postponed a special session focused on federal coronavirus aid hasn’t spurred a requirement for lawmakers there to wear masks either… Republican senators were photographed not wearing masks during a caucus retreat with GOP Gov. Mike Parson… [State] Senators have been encouraged to wear masks, and many have done so as they move around through public spaces,’ Senate President Pro Tem Dave Schatz said. ‘It is, however, ultimately up to each individual to make that decision.’” Associated Press, November 22nd.

The problem is literally getting from “here to there,” when vaccines have inoculated enough people to trigger that cherished but elusive herd immunity. As Sweden has discovered the hard way, there is no herd immunity without a vaccine. It would seem to be a very harsh reality to face that, even with a vaccine on the immediate horizon, people are so impatient, so driven either by mythology or believing that medical advice is a political statement, that they are willing to face death or inflict death or severe suffering on family members, friends and fellow workers to prove their right-wing political choices. We could easily see another million plus infections and hundreds of thousands of deaths, most avoidable and unnecessary. “Thank you so much, Republican legislators.” Mister Covid.

I’m Peter Dekom, and I wonder what gives other people the right to force me to stay at home to avoid a preventable virus that they are only helping to spread.


Tuesday, November 24, 2020

A Trump Coup D'état? No Gun

Perhaps it’s because the world finds Donald Trump’s continued claims he won the election by “a lot” to be so incredulous, the United States has such a powerful system of constitutionally based laws, that few are describing what seems to be going on as an attempted coup d'état. According to Wikipedia, a coup d'état typically is “an illegal, unconstitutional seizure of power by a political faction… usually through violent means.” But that phrase is increasingly finding it way into the international press… and even here in the United States.

We haven’t seen the normal accompanying violence, despite plenty very clear threats that there will be from Trump-supporting extremists including private militia, but it is clear that so many of Trump’s constituents have no intention of letting Joe Biden become President on January 21st. To other Trump supporters, even if Biden is sworn in formally, they will not recognize the results unless and until Donald Trump concedes and withdraws his claim of a fraudulent and rigged election. No one is expecting Trump to make that statement… now or ever.

The lack of immediate violence is not an essential part of the definition of a coup. It’s simply an extra-legal attempt to seize power. Despite 30 lawsuits filed by the Trump organization, his supporters and various facets of the Republican Party, there has not been a single successful judicial ruling according any path to reverse the election. Trump’s pleas to GOP state legislators, in states he lost, to usurp what he has labeled, without a shred of evidence, widespread election fraud, to simply replace the “elected” members of the state’s Electoral College with their GOP designees, have uniformly fallen on deaf ears. 

Trump has even summoned Michigan GOP election representatives to the White House to pressure them not to certify the election results. They simply responded that they would fulfill their legal obligations. And did. Some of the states he or folks like Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) have pushed to dump opposing ballots, or substitute GOP Electors, actually have statutes that require Electors to be selected only by voters. But a vast horde of Trump supporters – some telling the BBC that “Trump clearly knows something that we do not” – are completely convinced that the Democrats stole the election. That the Dems lost seats in the House would suggest what a bad job they did in that “theft”… goes without comment.

Still, the efforts to disqualify opposing votes, nullify state election results by reason of some nefarious deep state conspiracy theory or fraudulent balloting – all without evidence – continue. As mainstream law firms cease representing Trump’s position, as Rudy Giuliani (now leading the litigation effort) – with hair dye dripping down his face (pictured above) – continues to argue before judges that the fraud is so obvious that Biden’s election victories obvious must be nullified. Unsuccessfully. That the same ballots that supported Biden are often the same ballots that elected GOP Senators and Representatives seems to be lost in translation.

Triggering a statutorily permitted – loser pays – recount in two Wisconsin urban and highly Democratic counties where Trump was trounced by Joe Biden, most of the Trump/GOP appointed recount “observers” clearly intended a more active and disruptive role: “Election officials in Wisconsin’s largest county accused observers for President Donald Trump on Saturday [11/21] of seeking to obstruct a recount of the presidential results, in some instances by objecting to every ballot tabulators pulled to count.

“Trump requested the recount in Milwaukee and Dane counties, both heavily liberal, in hopes of undoing Democrat Joe Biden's victory by about 20,600 votes. With no precedent for a recount reversing such a large margin, Trump's strategy is widely seen as aimed at an eventual court challenge, part of a push in key states to undo his election loss.

“A steady stream of Republican complaints in Milwaukee was putting the recount far behind schedule, county clerk George Christenson said. He said many Trump observers were breaking rules by constantly interrupting vote counters with questions and comments… ‘That’s unacceptable,’ he said. He said some of the Trump observers ‘clearly don't know what they are doing.’

“Tim Posnanski, a county election commissioner, told his fellow commissioners there appeared to be two Trump representatives at some tables where tabulators were counting ballots, violating rules that call for one observer from each campaign per table. Posnanski said some Trump representatives seemed to be posing as independents.

“At one recount table, a Trump observer objected to every ballot that tabulators pulled from a bag simply because they were folded, election officials told the panel… Posnanski called it ‘prima facie evidence of bad faith by the Trump campaign.’ He added later: ‘I want to know what is going on and why there continues to be obstruction.’

“Joe Voiland, a lawyer speaking to commission members on behalf of the Trump campaign, denied his side was acting in bad faith… ‘I want to get to the point of dialing everything down … and not yelling at each other,’ Voiland said.

“At least one Trump observer was escorted out of the building by sheriff’s deputies Saturday after pushing an election official who had lifted her coat from an observer chair. Another Trump observer was removed Friday [11/20] for not wearing a face mask properly as required.” Associated Press, November 22nd.

Meanwhile, Trump is hardly a functional President at any level. Even as Americans are contracting COVID-19 in record numbers, pushing the death toll to accelerating heights, until November 23rd,Trump refused to allow the incoming administration to access GSA transition funds and government personnel to prepare to deal with this escalating crisis and set the needed deployment of imminently available vaccines. Tens if not hundreds of thousands of Americans will die by reason of this delay. No one is sure how much actual cooperation the Biden administration will be allowed during this process. 

Other than his usual “fake news” tweets – even Fox News is rebelling – Trump has all but disappeared from governance. “President Trump has refused to concede and taken ever more brazen steps, legally and politically, to reverse his election defeat. Yet he’s shown little sign of performing the job he’s trying so hard to keep. On Saturday [11/21], Trump left the virtual G-20 summit to play golf as other leaders, including those of Germany, France, South Korea and Italy, discussed by video a global response to the worsening pandemic.” Los Angeles Times, November 22nd. 

The United States seems more like a banana republic with an ousted dictator literally trying to bury a clear vote of the people. And in those countries, when they really do allow a change at the top, the deposed autocrat is often charged with treason or simply escapes to live in a friendly power. Trump’s position is so completely unsustainable that, so far at least, the actual government is not taking his efforts seriously, the courts are uniformly resisting his attempt to usurp election results, we do not have to move our legal inquiry further. But if indeed, genuine shooting (armed insurrection) starts…

I’m Peter Dekom, and lest we believe that Joe Biden has a clear mandate to change the course of American policy, remember that seventy-three million Americans voted for Donald Trump, albeit over five and a half million fewer than voted for Biden.



Monday, November 23, 2020

The Kill List

New York born Darrell Lamont Phelps (a former stand-up comic turned journalist) is suing the US government, because he believes that as a journalist, traveling deep within jihadist circles to interview militants in various organizations labeled by the US government as terrorists, he has been specifically targeted by the federal government for elimination. Having been the subject of US supported shelling, missile and drone strikes, his lawsuit sought to discover whether he actually was on an official federal “kill list.” The government, claiming statutory privilege under a judicially vetted state’s secret law, refused to provide that information – one way or the other – claiming releasing such information would compromise US security and military operations. 

So far, so good. Makes sense. Let’s dig a little more. “Phelps grew up in Mount Vernon, New York; he attended Mount Vernon High School, then studied creative writing at Purchase College SUNY, before going on to work in stand-up comedy. He converted to Islam [and changed his name to Bilal Abdul Kareem], partly due to its ‘emphasis on clean living’, travelled to Egypt to study Arabic, where he later obtained a presenting role with Saudi- funded television channel, Huda TV. After leaving Huda TV, due to ‘disagreements’, he travelled to Rwanda and Libya to film documentaries, before arriving in Syria in 2012 where he was first hosted by Ahrar al-Sham. 

“After initially working with Western mainstream news outlets, such as Sky News and the BBC [including CNN], he helped found ‘On The Ground News’. Publishing on Facebook, Twitter and YouTube, its official website claims it is ‘committed to delivering accurate English language news to a Western audience regarding the Syrian crisis’.” Wikipedia. But Kareem (nee Phleps) had reason to believe that he was on a US hit list and wanted to find out.

“While [Kareem] harshly criticizes the jihadists of the Islamic State, he has done extensive interviews with members of the Syrian affiliate of Al Qaeda. In one, a prominent jihadist cleric from Saudi Arabia explains why joining the jihad in Syria is a religious obligation and says that fighters in Syria are ‘the first line of defense’ against the Shiites… Such interviews have led critics to brand Mr. Abdul Kareem a jihadist propagandist… The Syrian government and its Russian allies say he cavorts with terrorists. Although the United States has taken no public stance on his work, terrorism analysts say he provides an uncritical, English-language platform for jihadists.” New York Times, March 10, 2017.

Having lost at the trial court level – the government was not required to turn over any secret information – the case (Kareem vs Haspel, U.S. Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia) moved up into the federal appellate court. What makes this case stand out, why I elected to blog about it, is not whether or not the federal government has a reasonable right to protect state secrets, which it does, but where the oral arguments went when it came to the notion of whether there were circumstances where the United States government could elect to kill a US citizen without the normal judicial due process… by a secret order. Kareem claims he was the wrongful target of such an order. The federal lawyer insisted the government could, under certain circumstances, order the extrajudicial execution of an American citizen.

“Drawing alarm at the D.C. Circuit, a lawyer for the United States argued Monday [11/16] that the government has the power to kill its citizens without judicial oversight when state secrets are involved… ‘Do you appreciate how extraordinary that proposition is?’ U.S. Circuit Judge Patricia Millett asked Justice Department attorney Bradley Hinshelwood, paraphrasing his claim as giving the government the ability to ‘unilaterally decide to kill U.S. citizens.’… “[T]he Justice Department’s Hinshelwood conceded… that a strike against a U.S. citizen is a serious undertaking. Where the judiciary can step in, he said, is in ensuring that the state-secrets privilege was appropriately applied.

“But Kareem’s attorney, Tara Jordan Plochocki, argued the government was radically expanding sovereignty, domestically and abroad, allowed under state-secrets privilege… ‘Whether that’s in a parking lot in the United States or abroad in Syria, the government has claimed — for the first time ever in this case — that it has unfettered and unreviewable discretion to kill US citizens at will,’ Plochocki said. 

“Shrugging off Kareem’s claims as baseless speculation, the government argued the alleged airstrikes occurred at a time when Syria was wracked by civil war… ‘In all of these circumstances, he’s not even the only person present, much less is there anything to suggest that he’s actually the target of any of these specific attacks,’ Hinshelwood said. 

“The three-judge panel took seriously the defense that bombs pummeled Syria in 2016 as the conflict between the Assad regime and rebel groups roared… U.S. Circuit Judge Karen Henderson, a George H. W. Bush appointee, said she viewed it as a ‘spectacular delusion of grandeur’ that Kareem claims a series of U.S. missiles were aimed at him.” Courthouse News Service, November 16th.  

No decision was announced but is expected soon. The appellate court could remand the case for further findings, perhaps in camera, simply affirm the lower court’s finding or articulate more precise standards for this kind of discovery. Would Kareem have to offer more proof, beyond mere serendipity? Where would get that proof if not from the government?

The appellate court is unlikely to address whether the US government can target US citizens for execution without normal due process, since that is not the main issue in the case. But we should all note that the government believes that it can, in secret but provided certain internal standards and procedures are met, kill US citizens without a normal trial. But how do we know those standards are being followed? What if a rogue government simply wanted to off its enemies under the guise of national security? What happens if a US-born citizen becomes the militant leader of a group that has declared war on the United States? Interesting. What do you think should be the solution?

I’m Peter Dekom, and hard cases can often produce bad law, but we do live in trying times that defy traditional answers.


Sunday, November 22, 2020

Except for an Erosion in Election Confidence and Weakening of Democracy – No Change

Read that title over again. That’s a huge “except.” It flies in the face of almost two dozen judicial opinions – tossing out unsubstantiated claims of mass conspiracy to “steal the election,” lack of access to vote counts by GOP observers or any out-of-the-exceptionally-minor-ordinary voter fraud or exclusions – election officials (from both parties) almost unanimously vouching for the sanctity of the election, and even the election integrity assurances from Trump’s appointed director of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), who was fired by Trump for letting his agency officially tell the American people that the election was “‘the most secure in American history.”

Aside from the damage done by Trump’s last minute firings and replacements, his imposition of executive orders and policy mandates that are clearly precisely the opposite of Biden’s stated goals or the continued lack of preparedness to administer a probable vaccine or vet (through the FBI) prospective cabinet appointees by reason of denying the President-elect normal transition funding, access to personnel and information, Donald Trump has damaged our own belief in our very democracy and election process. He has also made the United States the international poster child for hypocrisy when it comes to championing and believing in representative democracy.

What is abundantly clear is that Joe Biden will be sworn in as the next President of the United States on January 20th. What is equally clear is that Donald Trump, supported by most elected Republicans, has and will continue to undercut Biden’s credibility and do everything in his/their power to reverse that result. It won’t put Trump in for a second term; it has already perhaps irretrievably damaged the nation… internally, making unification elusive at best, and externally, in the eyes of allies looking for a path to reconnect with an America they no longer recognize.

Melanie Mason, writing for the November 19th Los Angeles Times, presents the results of a post-election review by the University of Southern California (a joint survey by Dornsife Center for Economic and Social Research and the Dornsife Center for the Political Future). Bottom line: “President Trump’s repeated — and baseless — insistence that widespread fraud undermined this month’s presidential election has left a mark on Americans’ faith in the voting process…

“Using a 0-100 scale to measure their confidence that all ballots were tallied correctly, the survey found the average ranking from voters was a middling 58. Democrats gave higher marks — 79 — that the vote count was accurate, while Republicans on the whole rated their confidence in the election results’ accuracy at just 34…

“Only 35% of respondents said they believed the country was headed in the right direction, a nearly 10-point drop from 2016. The outlook varied by party, reflecting the hyperpolarized electorate — more than three-quarters of Biden voters said they thought the nation was on the wrong track before the race was called for him, but after he was declared president-elect, 60% of his supporters said they believed the country was headed in the right direction.

“In the immediate aftermath of the election, 56% of Trump voters said the country was on the wrong track; that glum view increased to 76% of Trump supporters after the race was called for Biden… The partisan divide extended to attitudes toward voting by mail. Nearly three-quarters of Trump supporters said the increase in mail-in ballots led to voter fraud, while nearly 80% of Biden supporters disagreed.” By the way, Trump voted by mail.

What this means is that most Americans currently do not believe in the United States of America. We’re in a heap of trouble – from the pandemic which is exploding again, the polarization which is as bad as it has been since our Civil War and our COVID-slammed economy which has shifted to a new accelerating level of decline – and we really need to muster our gumption, our patriotism and our commitment to fix what is obviously wrong. But it is that vision for a fix that is mired partly in mythology – where wearing a virus-resistant mask is not a medical necessity but a political statement and where deep state pedophilia conspiracy theories are indirectly supported by the President… and even several newly elected members of Congress. When facts don’t matter, how can repairs be implemented?

And if Americans do not believe in their country, if their only solution is either pure mythology or “my way is the only way,” exactly why should Americans care if their nation stays together? And if we do not care, can it? Will it? Can Biden attempt to find unity, when Trump’s toxicity is focused on keeping us angry at each other, at each other’s throats and more deeply polarized than we have been in over a century and a half?

I’m Peter Dekom, and if you truly care, stop and listen to the logic and wants of the rational segment of the opposing point of view… and find that middle ground that you can live with.


Saturday, November 21, 2020

Priorities – International: Iran



Treaties, in theory, require Senate ratification to be truly binding, but many treaties never reach that legislative body. Instead, the President authorizes a treaty to be negotiated (sometimes with direct involvement by the President), approves the result and then instructs governmental agencies and diplomats to implement its dictates whether or not that treaty is submitted to the Senate. Treaties that contain financial commitments either require Congressional approval or approval for the specific funding in question. 

Aside from the general notion that President Biden has a lot of bridge-mending and treaty reaffirmation on his agenda, he is also operating under a new perception of a general and perhaps irreversible decline in American political and economic power and influence. Add the probable complexity of a GOP-controlled Senate hell-bent on gridlock. For nations that had once trusted America at its word, they have become acutely aware that it does not take much, just the election of a president who disagrees with the substance of past promises, for the United States to renege. That’s a tough place to be in for any leader trying to step back into a policy of international engagement and cooperation.

We may assume that even though it has only been a few days since the United States officially implemented its earlier termination of its commitment to the Paris climate accord, restoring that status will be an easy button for the new President. Not so simple, however, are the nuclear threats from North Korea, which both has a nuclear arsenal and the capacity to deliver those weapons even to targets on American soil, and Iran, which has been suffering from additional US sanctions since Donald Trump pulled the United States out of the six-party UN Iran-nuclear-containment accord two and a half years ago. After 40 years of never-ending US-Iran mutual brinksmanship and constant animas, nothing remotely had brought Iran to the negotiating table until the accord.

Korea will evolve, but pressure to restore a treaty to halt further development of an Iranian nuclear weapons capacity will be almost immediate. In ending US participation in the Iran accord, Trump responded primarily to Israeli pressure, supported heavily by his evangelical base. Israel believed the accord accomplished little. Military intelligence had informed Trump that Iran had not breached its obligations when Trump announced US withdrawal. Many in this country believed that once the US pulled out and reimposed as well as expanded sanctions, Tehran would slowly come begging for relief and give both the United States and Israel exactly what they wanted. They were wrong again; Iran dug in its heels despite the pain. 

“[After] President Donald Trump announced the U.S withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal, Tehran has resumed its enrichment of uranium, restarted research and development on advanced centrifuges, and expanded its stockpile of nuclear fuel, cutting in half the time it would need to produce enough weapons-grade fuel to build a nuclear bomb… ‘Iran is manifestly closer to being able to produce a nuclear weapon than they were two years ago,’ said Richard Nephew, who participated in negotiations on the landmark nuclear deal in 2015 [on behalf of the Obama administration].

“While there is no evidence Tehran is preparing a dash for a nuclear weapon, the Iranian advances raise questions about the success of the [Trump] White House’s so-called ‘maximum pressure’ campaign, which is aimed at forcing Iran through the imposition of ever more stringent sanctions to accept greater constraints on its political and military support for regional militias and the development of its ballistic missile program.

“The effort—which has severely damaged Iran’s economy—has yet to temper Iran’s nuclear ambitions, instead prompting Tehran to resume nuclear activities prohibited by the nuclear pact, which is formally known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, or JCPOA. It has also eroded Washington’s credibility even among many of its traditional allies and placed increasing strains on America’s diplomatic partnerships.” ForeignPolicy.com, May 8th. The rift between the United States widened when a US drone strike in Iraq took out a hallowed Iranian general: “Iran announced it would no longer abide by the [entire] JCPOA after the U.S. assassination of top commander Major General Qassem Soleimani in Iraq in January.” Newsweek, November 6th.

Israel’s current Netanyahu regime, profoundly pro-Trump, was obviously displeased at the outcome of our election. They were aware that Biden intended to try to restore that JCPOA in one version or another. “According to The Jerusalem Post, Settlements Minister Tzachi Hanegbi told Army Radio Wednesday [11/4] that Biden's position could result in war, firing the starting gun for anti-Iran deal pressure from Israel.

“‘Biden has said openly for a long time that he will go back to the nuclear agreement,’ Hanegbi said of the Iran deal… ‘I see that as something that will lead to a confrontation between Israel and Iran.’… Biden is a pro-Israel candidate, and dismissed calls from the progressive wing of his party to re-evaluate America's relationship with its long-time ally… Democratic critics of Israel argue that Netanyahu has overseen a raft of human rights abuses; pushed ahead with settlements on Palestinian land considered illegal by the United Nations and most of the international community; and annexed occupied foreign land, with the threat to do the same in parts of the West Bank.

“But Biden has vowed an ‘unshakeable’ commitment to Israeli security. His administration is likely to try and rebuild bridges with Palestinian representatives burned by Trump, but Biden is not expected to chart a radically different path on Israel regardless of concerns about Netanyahu's conduct and politics… Though Hanegbi told Army Radio he is not generally concerned about a Biden administration, the former vice president's willingness to re-engage with Iran is a problem for him, Netanyahu and much of Israel… He said the JCPOA was ‘mistaken—and that's an understatement... If Biden stays with that policy, there will, in the end, be a violent confrontation between Israel and Iran,’ he warned…

“Biden will have to get Tehran to comply again, but has also suggested he would try and curb Iran's ballistic missile program and its use of regional proxies… Experts are skeptical he will succeed. And he has a small window—in June the Iranian presidency will change hands, and most expect a hardline conservative to take power.” Newsweek. In 2015, Israel also had suggested that the original JCPOA would result in a war between Israel and Iran, which did not happen. Meanwhile, Russia has taken advantage of this impasse and is considering selling arms (new jets, defensive radar/missile systems akin to what they gave to Syria, etc.) to Iran. 

But perhaps that small window has opened a bit more, depending on what the word “compensate” really means in this context, as reported by the November 8th Associated Press: “Iran's president called on President-elect Joe Biden to ‘compensate for past mistakes’ and return the U.S. to Tehran's 2015 nuclear deal with world powers, a state-run news agency reported Sunday [11/8]… Hassan Rouhani's comments mark the highest-level response from Iran to Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris clinching the Nov. 3 election.

“‘Now, an opportunity has come up for the next U.S. administration to compensate for past mistakes and return to the path of complying with international agreements through respect of international norms,’ the state-run IRNA news agency quoted him as saying.” President-elect Biden obviously has a lot on his plate, but these treaty opportunities come with their own timelines and stress points. Outside of a military solution, which could easily get out of hand (as our wars in the Islamic world have proven repeatedly), a treaty with Iran, even if flawed, is the only truly viable path.

I’m Peter Dekom, and diplomacy by force often produces more resistance than compliance with the desired goals… unless the pressing party is prepared to go to war.


 


Friday, November 20, 2020

International Priorities - China Unstrained


Make no mistake; China may be such a large and necessary political and economic relationship that we cannot ignore, but China has definite aspirations that are totally focused on usurping and replacing American global influence. They are not and have never been our friend or trusted ally. Why is China’s brutal regime remotely attractive to so many in the world, while the US model seems to be fading and unable to deal with natural/medical disasters, slipping rapidly into dwindling global influence in virtually every corner of the world?

As the total refusal by the People’s Republic of China to honor its 1984 (effective 1997) treaty with the UK, to retain the British governance system for Hong Kong and political freedom until 2047, devolved into total political repression (pictured above), a reversal of democratic guarantees and mass arrests of people exercising the rights they were promised, many expected the world to press back… hard. The pandemic was now our focus. The once powerful America was distracted and deflected. The rise of the de facto Cold War rising between the United States and the PRC effectively left China without any potential for an American pushback. The US has thus effectively disqualified itself from any meaningful power or influence against Chinese expansionism. Kim Jong-un is also smiling.

Instead, the US pursuit of a policy of intentional isolationism, burning communications bridges with the PRC in search of someone to blame for the pandemic, blowing out trade agreements that hurt American farmers a whole lot more than the functioning Chinese economy, and unilaterally withdrawing from treaties and alliances, have left American foreign policy in tatters. There is a very real question as to whether the world will ever trust us again… when it was so easy for a US president to undo decades of American priorities in a single presidential term. Especially as Donald Trump has worked overtime to delegitimize the entire American election process. China has joyfully used compromised American power to act with no genuine outside restraint.

We know, for example, that China’s brutality has totally crushed Muslim Uighurs in Xinjiang Province in western China: “[A leak of internal Chinese documents] was made to the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ), which has worked with 17 media partners, including BBC Panorama and The Guardian newspaper in the UK… The investigation has found new evidence which undermines Beijing's claim that the detention camps, which have been built across Xinjiang in the past three years, are for voluntary re-education purposes to counter extremism.

“About a million people - mostly from the Muslim Uighur community - are thought to have been detained without trial…  The leaked Chinese government documents, which the ICIJ have labelled ‘The China Cables,’ include a nine-page memo sent out in 2017 by Zhu Hailun, then deputy-secretary of Xinjiang's Communist Party and the region's top security official, to those who run the camps… The instructions make it clear that the camps should be run as high security prisons, with strict discipline, punishments and no escapes.” BBC.com, 11/24/19.

China’s Belt and Road Initiative, effectively lending massive infrastructure funds to enable greater trade with the PRC to nations around the world, is rapidly replacing the United States as it withdraws foreign aid globally. Loans that wouldn’t realistically be timely repaid by most debtors even without an economy-decimating pandemic are used as bargaining chips that China unhesitatingly is willing to call. As the United States has become an unreliable source of agricultural goods – represented particularly well by American soybean farmers who seem to have permanently lost their biggest market – it has instead turned to build new supply lines, permanent ones, from other nations with a particular focus on South America and Africa. Brazil’s Mata Grosso, for example, is rapidly becoming one of China’s largest agricultural sources.

Having used landfill techniques to build a massive new and obviously militarized island (in the Spratly chain within the South China Sea), China is asserting its claims to that entire ocean region to the consternation of regional nations. US Naval vessels and aircraft continue to press against PRC claims to regional sovereignty, but American support for local governments challenges to Chinese claims has been shallow and wavering. It even gets down to natural resources; to China, the local undersea minerals and fossil fuels and associated fishing rights belong solely to them.

Writing for the November 15th Los Angeles Times, Shashank Bengali and Vo Kieu Bao Uyen provide a brutal example of China’s usurping traditional fishing lanes that have been used for centuries by regional nations. “On a warm, cloudless morning in June, a giant vessel blasted through the still waters of the South China Sea toward a wooden fishing boat painted in cerulean blue and flying the red flag of Vietnam.

“The veteran fishing captain cranked up the engine to flee, but the approaching ship dropped two motorized dinghies into the sea with uniformed officers aboard. The rubber crafts raced along either side of the fishing boat, squeezing it like a pincer… As the captain slowed to avoid a collision, the large ship was soon upon them. The large letters across its steel hull read: China.

“Crammed into their cabin for safety, the 17 men were knocked to the deck by a jolt that nearly tipped the boat. Then another. And another. ‘Like war,’ recalled crew member Nguyen Day… The Chinese vessel smashed the boat repeatedly, damaging the cabin. Four fishermen tumbled overboard. As the officers pulled them from the water, Day, 41, and the other Vietnamese men piled into lifeboats and watched their craft — laden with several hundred pounds of tuna, mackerel, grouper and flying fish — begin to float away.

“The June 10 attack was part of Beijing’s hard-nosed offensive in the South China Sea, where Chinese vessels are using increasingly aggressive tactics to deter rival nations and stake control over the strategic waterway.

“Unfazed by rising global criticism, China’s navy, coast guard and paramilitary fleet have rammed fishing boats, harassed oil exploration vessels, held combat drills and shadowed U.S. naval patrols. The escalating show of force has overwhelmed smaller Southeast Asian states that also claim parts of the sea, one of the world’s busiest fishing and trade corridors and a repository of untapped oil and natural gas… Beijing’s maritime expansionism illustrates not only the Chinese Communist Party’s growing military might but also its willingness to defy neighbors and international laws to fulfill President Xi Jinping’s sweeping visions of power.”

Chinese President Xi Jinping is China’s first “elected” (not by the people but by the Party) autocrat hellbent on developing lifetime rule based on a cult of personality that we last witnessed in the 1970s with Mao Zedong. His expansionist goals, his willingness to use all means to suppress oppression, are unambiguous. When challenged on that approach, he reminds the world that China has contained the novel coronavirus and is the only major economy on earth for which the IMF projected GDP growth (4.9% to be exact). The reason: because the PRC used force to contain the virus and anyone infected, and that process worked as democracies struggled. He is eager to point out Trump’s failures – and hence “American” failures – combined with the President’s denial of our election results and that the United States, with 4% of the world’s population and 20% of COVID infections, are clear evidence that China’s path is the correct path for everybody.

Still, China is anything but gentle in its approach. “In its strategic quest to dominate the waterway separating the Asian mainland from the island of Borneo and the Philippine archipelago, China has built military outposts on disputed islands and reefs that, according to Xi, ‘are Chinese territory since ancient times … left to us by our ancestors.’ The network of bases, harbors and landing strips deep in international waters has created a buffer for China’s southern coastline, further encircled Taiwan and challenged the Pentagon’s ability to move ships into Asia.

“‘It appears that China is rapidly developing the capabilities to exclude other navies from the South China Sea,’ Bill Hayton, an author and associate fellow at the Chatham House think tank, told a congressional commission in September… Under the Trump administration — which has called China a ‘bully’ seeking a ‘maritime empire’ — the U.S. sailed more warships than normal through the region in 2020 to assert navigation rights. But the operations have done nothing to claw back the islets and waters that five Southeast Asian nations and Taiwan claim Beijing has usurped.” LA Times. Remember, when Donald Trump tweeted that he had won a second term by a large margin, the official responsive tweet from the China’s People’s Daily was "HaHa🤣."

President-elect Joe Biden faces a hostile China that is actually open to engage the United States towards some semblance of re-normalization between the two nations. But we are unlikely to recapture the level of agricultural sales we have lost. Given the tariff wars, China is unlikely to trust us as reliable foodstuff suppliers. Yet our economy is a vital component of their economic solidity, so some levels of compromise are likely. Biden should press back on China’s brutality but stop the inane policy of blame. 

As much as Biden must let China know that it no longer has free reign to assert is military and economic power without consequence, in the region or in the rest of the world, he also needs to restore American aid to those nations that have been forced to turn to China as we withdrew, engage and rejoin treaties – from climate change and nuclear containment to multinational trade agreements – that create a bastion against China’s efforts to become the dominant global power. Bilateral treaties and bully tactics have only made us weaker. Biden also has to prove to the world that a democracy is completely able to contain the coronavirus. It’s a very big challenge.

I’m Peter Dekom, and Joe Biden has to let the world that the photographs of repression and naval confrontation are the accurate depictions of the true China… and not the United States… if we are ever to recapture even close to that influence that has been slip-sliding away.