America borrows. Forget about
corporate debt. Consumer credit card debt now tops a trillion dollars with
average outstanding balances approaching $6.5 thousand. 70 million Americans
don’t pay off their monthly balances, carrying credit card debt at an average
APR of 16.6%. All according MagnifyMoney.com, January 23rd. But that
pales in comparison to the aggregation of outstanding student loans, often
carried for decades. As America’s college graduates amass personal debt – now
well-past the aggregate $1.5 trillion mark, averaging over $30 thousand per
graduate – they get married and start families later, buy homes later, often
buy cheaper cars or do not buy cars at all and tend to consume at a lower level
than past generations. For those attending professional schools – medical, law
and business schools, where debt is the major source of tuition – that debt can
easily spiral into six figures. See the March 2nd Student Loan
Report from StudentLoans.net.
As rich families bribe and lie their
teenaged children into prestigious colleges and universities (the purported
Huffman/Loughlin path), or “donate with wink-wink expectations” (the Trump/
Kushner path), such “expectations and privileges of the mega-rich” dominate the
headlines. But the bigger story is how ordinary young people who do get into
their respective colleges afford their education. How they graduate and enter
the most expensive housing market (as an average percentage of income) in our
history facing jobs that are threatened with near-term
artificially-intelligence-driven obsolescence… and pay off their student loans,
severely impacted by bankruptcy laws amended in 2005 specifically to protect
lenders against student loan defaults. It is just another side of the
“privileged classes” being better-prepared for and able to pay for higher
education without burdensome loans or distracting job school-term requirements.
Other than token charges and housing,
anyone going to school in Germany – anyone! – can get a magnificent education (even
in English) for free. Good schools, academically prestigious with outstanding
professors and curricula. There was a time in the United States where a high
school grad could at least attend a local community college for free and often
a state college or university without any significant tuition charges. Once
upon a time, long, long ago.
Despite political platform pledges,
austerity and the bizarre need to reduce taxes for the rich (which absolutely
does not create solid new jobs) have pushed state legislatures into a seemingly
never-ending path of raising state tuition fees. Recently, there has been a
trend to stabilize those costs, but tuition in the United States – fully
corrected for inflation – has never been higher. At both public and private
institutions. And since we live in an increasingly complex,
technologically/financially-driven world, going beyond high school at some
level is almost a prerequisite to getting a decent job these days. This job
trend has fueled the exceptionally-high demand for post-secondary education,
which demand has only driven tuition costs higher faster.
Everybody understands that this
rising debt is a huge problem for the country as a whole. Not only does it
exacerbate already-horrific income inequality, but without serious increases in
our national skill-sets and education, the United States will continue to fall
behind vis-à-vis its once-heralded competitive advantage. Unable to grow its
own expertise and facing serious restrictions as to importing qualified and
educated professionals from overseas because of current immigration policies,
the United States would paint itself into a corner of significant disadvantage.
The Trump administration, despite
major cuts to education in its 2019 budget request to Congress, is aware of the
student debt issue, but what we can glean from there statements – assuming they
reverse their budget request – their focus is a mixture of good and bad news
for students. The March 20th Los Angeles Times explains:
“The biggest debt holders are not the
students who attend the nonprofit and public institutions that dominate in
higher education, but those who go to for-profit colleges. These students
account for only about 13% of all college students, but they are responsible
for more than half of all student loan defaults. One reason for the high level
of defaults is that many for-profit colleges promise students far more than
they deliver in marketable skills, leaving them without the careers they had
expected.
“For better and worse, President
Trump addressed both of these issues in a plan for higher education announced
Monday. The details are sketchy at this point, but there are enough good ideas
to start a discussion in Congress — and enough worrisome elements to merit
caution.
“Among the most promising requests by
the administration — requests, because they would need congressional approval —
are the ones that would streamline both the application and repayment for
federal student loans. There would be one income-driven repayment plan for each
level of higher education: Undergraduates would pay 12.5% of their
discretionary income for 15 years; anything unpaid at that point would be
forgiven. That’s a reasonable pace, allowing them to finish five years earlier
than current plans do. But graduate students would pay for 30 years at the same
rate, five years longer than they currently do. Borrowers would also receive
more financial aid counseling at the front end, so that they understand the
terms of their loans (and the chances that they won’t be able to pay them
back), enabling them to make more informed financial decisions.
“Of more concern is the proposal to
limit how much graduate students can borrow in federal loans; there is
currently no restriction. The goal is partly to reduce some of the crushing
debt — much of which ends up being a load on taxpayers. The administration also
hopes that if graduate students can’t borrow up to the full cost of the
program, as they can now, graduate schools will have less incentive to
continually raise prices.
“The effect of this change on
students, however, could be drastic, especially for low-income students. Rather
than reducing their borrowing, many students and their families would probably
turn to private, rather than federal, lenders, receiving less favorable terms.
Low-income families might not be able to get these loans at all, limiting the
ability of the people who need the most help to attend graduate school…
“The majority of loans at for-profit
colleges go into default, yet Trump has gone out of his way to free the schools
from Obama-era regulations intended to crack down on shady marketing and low
performance. Trump’s emphasis on efficient, short-term vocational training is
welcome; not everyone needs to go to college. But loans should be provided only
for accredited programs with strong records of sending their students on to
successful careers. The president surely should know the difference between
that and the kinds of programs that should not qualify for federal loans; he
ran a real estate training business that closed after paying $25 million to
settle lawsuits claiming misleading marketing practices. Taxpayers shouldn’t be
footing loans for institutions that resemble Trump University.” Yet education
is the real job creator in this nation!
Until we make post-secondary
education more accessible and affordable, the biggest loser will be the United
States as whole. Rich families don’t have access/ affordability issues, so the
income gap can only widen under the weight of the current system, even if
adjusted in accordance with the Trump proposals. And protecting fraud-meisters
has to stop, even though that goal has been a major effort from Trump’s
Department of Education Secretary, Betsy DeVos.
I’m Peter Dekom, and the Piper has entered
the building and is demanding payment.
For students like me... Higher Education Loand has proven to be a boon over the years.. Thanks for sharing this lovely article.
ReplyDeleteWe offer loan from €100,000.00 to €200,000,00, at affordable interest rate and with no credit check ,we offer Personal loans, debt consolidation loans, venture capital, business loans, education loans, home loans or “loans for any reason!”? We have a fixed 3% interest rate!!!
ReplyDeleteEmail: Guaranteeloanoffer@outlook.com or contact on WhatsApp @ +38972751056